Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

Part Two: Why Vote People:
I'm not going to include myself, for obvious reasons.
~~~
A little more roles analysis:
Flabort is SK/vigilante.
All the others have no real verification(except origamiscienceguy, but what proof do we have that he's telling the truth?).
OSG claims that hector is town(exempting him from being the clone lord if OSG is telling the truth).
So we have 3 candidates for being the Clone Lord, and 4 for being cultists(let's assume we're dealing with a scenario that has the Clone Lord and a cultist).
So... here's our possibilities.

CL......................cultist
Hector                 flabort
Hector                 TigerDude
Hector                 OSG
TigerDude            flabort
TigerDude            OSG
TigerDude            Hector
OSG                     flabort
OSG                     TigerDude
OSG                     Hector
~~~
Now because I'm lazy I'd like someone else to write the pros and cons of each possibility, but if necessary I'll do it myself.

[origamiscienceguy]

You forgot a few.
CL...................cultist
FallacyofUrist    Hector
FallacyofUrist    OSG
FallacyofUrist    Flabort
FallacyofUrist    Sabertooth

[FallacyofUrist]

Fiiiiiiine. If you want those included, go ahead.

[hector13]

What's this "Guardian Recruit" stuff, FoU?

[FallacyofUrist]

... vanilla townie.

[hector13]

Aye, but nowhere has it been said, before now. Not even DA has mentioned anything like that. Why not just say VT?

[FallacyofUrist]

It was somewhat mentioned... in flavor. You know, some players were recent recruits to the guardians with no powers yet...
It just sounded nicer to me.

[hector13]

It may sound nicer, but it also sounds like you know things you shouldn't, like role flavour names...

[FallacyofUrist]

...
get back to scum hunting.

[hector13]

Right back atcha

[FallacyofUrist]

Question one. Is origamiscienceguy telling the truth?
If he is, then you're town, if he's not, then you're likely cult and so is he, likely.
So possibility one- you being the clone lord and origamiscienceguy is covering for you.
Or possibility two- you being a VT as you claim and origamiscienceguy is telling the truth.
~~~
Possibility one action requirement- vote for you in order to win the game as town.
Possibility two action requirement- jump to alternate possibilities...
~~~
Possibility three- TigerDudeWhoNeedsToPost being the Clone Lord and has converted you/origamiscienceguy.
~~~
I'm somewhat weighted towards possibility three because of TigerDude's lurking and not responding to my attack post, plus you're just so active and scum hunting...
~~~
You know what? Enough already. TigerDude, my vote stays on you until you post, blast it. We can't really get this game on until you do.
Mod's convenience: SaberToothTiger.

[origamiscienceguy]

Question one. Is origamiscienceguy telling the truth?
If he is, then you're town, if he's not, then you're likely cult and so is he, likely.
So possibility one- you being the clone lord and origamiscienceguy is covering for you.
Or possibility two- you being a VT as you claim and origamiscienceguy is telling the truth.
~~~
Possibility one action requirement- vote for you in order to win the game as town.
Possibility two action requirement- jump to alternate possibilities...
~~~
Possibility three- TigerDudeWhoNeedsToPost being the Clone Lord and has converted you/origamiscienceguy.
~~~
I'm somewhat weighted towards possibility three because of TigerDude's lurking and not responding to my attack post, plus you're just so active and scum hunting...
~~~
You know what? Enough already. TigerDude, my vote stays on you until you post, blast it. We can't really get this game on until you do.
Mod's convenience: SaberToothTiger.

You are right that Sabertooth really needs to post. I don't see anything wrong with your analysis, but I would like to point out that almost every situation you indicated would still work if you were the clone lord.

[hector13]

Just 'cause I'm active, doesn't mean I'm not the CL

Possibility one is a sensible, if I were CL to have my cultist clear me... But not if I'm pushing them as cult.

Possibility two has issues. I can be telling the truth independent of OSG's claim. He might be trying to get me to view him positively if he is cult by "confirming" my claim, whether that's because he's the CL who converted the role, or the role that was converted by the CL.

If you're correct in your assertion that we're both being honest, neither of us are the CL, so it'd be between you, Saber and flabsy.

Why didn't you consider flabort as CL in those possibilities?

[FallacyofUrist]

Two players have been night killed. Flabort claims he did it and nobody else counterclaimed. Beyond absurdity- you know what? Let's consider some absurdity.

Suppose Flabort, not being a cultist, is the Clone Lord and has a nightkill that he can use instead of cloning people. And instead of cloning people, he decided to basically be a serial killer.
Wouldn't that be horrible.

Now I'm going to go design a bastard mod for a bit.

[hector13]

Would kinda like to point out that it is the Christmas weekend so... Pressure votes on Saber aren't necessarily going to get him to post. Particularly considering they haven't really worked before...