There could also be two thieves, with the second one rehiding the necklace upon catching wind of our intentions to search their culprit's cabin.
I know I'm hunting anti-town, not specifically mafia.
Qua is anti-town, and has a 'mafiakill' ability. Seems confused about being mafia or not, if word of Qua can be believed.
[Red Agent]
...
[Extra Action, Mafiakill, Day]
This is a anti-town roleflip.
It's also designed to make the player with that role not want to kill one specific player, specifically identified as town and usable as described.
But how many anti-town can we possibly have in a 7 player nightless game?
Could we have more than 2? 3 is the most I can imagine, and I think that very unlikely, even if the others don't have kills.
NJW: Extremely likely to be town.
CM: Likely to be town.
sof: more likely to be town than anti-town.
Now I die on the hill of
Max vs
Oliv.
Oliv's been on today, after D2 started. Still hasn't posted. Everything looks consistent to a Oliv being scum. Talk or die bud.
Max has not been on since D1 ended, roundabouts. Is super sus. Behaved perfectly consistently if Qua and Max are not teamed but are both anti-town, and Max and Qua need to find each other. Qua said "I'm your bud" and Max said....
Oliverz144, then.
If it's a gambit, then I'm proud of you and you deserve a second try.
If he's going to claim SK, I think we probably need to elim him. I'm not going to understand if people disagree.
Personally, I'd rather lynch the thief first if possible. A demoralized, outed SK doesn't matter that much and can probably be vigged in the night anyway. I won't say no to a Quarque lynch, but it seems like a waste.
I guess I understand that impulse. As things stand, would an Oliverz elim be more worthwhile?
Only extremely slightly, but I'm working with what I've got.
And then Max bails end of day, which if Max is anti-town, that's a lost partner that wasn't saved, and Max is again in a last-game-like position where he visibly tried to save Web and then, D2...
I like Max proposing the no elim here, I think, as I imagine him being passive at this point as town-elim. Not sure if I’ve seen it happen though… yeah, hard to say.
The word you're looking for is "utterly crushed". It's happened a few times, but I'm not sure if you were ever there.
I'm extremely open to the idea that Max may also be a godfather.
But I think NJW is pro-town and honest, however a 'insane cop' or a 'insane, short, simple mafia game' with a sane cop who is hands-tied... but a mafia also hands-tied... might work for the lulz.
Do we remove Oliv or Max first?
I sure hope one of them talks.... no. I hope they both talk.